News EnglishJune 5, 2008 12:24 pm

Gen McNeill
Gen McNeill says Nato has had successes in the eas

The outgoing American general in charge of Nato forces in Afghanistan for the past 15 months says the war against the Taleban is "under-resourced".

Gen Dan McNeill was speaking before handing command of Nato’s International Security Assistance Force (Isaf) to another American, Gen David McKiernan.

Isaf currently has 53,000 troops from 40 countries. But Gen McNeill said more manpower and equipment is needed.

The handover took place at an hour-long ceremony in the capital, Kabul.

It was attended by Afghan President Hamid Karzai, foreign ambassadors and a host of other dignitaries.

President Karzai warned the new general that his task would not be easy and that more lives would be lost before Afghanistan could stand on its own feet.

It is not clear how Gen McKiernan’s command will differ from that of his predecessor.

But he said that insurgents, criminals and others that stood in the way of Afghan progress would be dealt with.

Strong messages

The BBC’s Alastair Leithead in Kabul says Gen McNeill’s reputation in Afghanistan has been for straight talking and keeping out of politics.

Blast in Jalalabad 31 May
Attacks in Afghanistan increase ‘when there are peace talks in Pakistan’

But he had two strong messages as he prepared to handover control of Isaf to Gen McKiernan.

When he took over in February 2007 Isaf had 33,000 troops. Even though there are now 53,000 troops, Gen McNeill said that was still not enough.

"This is an under-resourced war and it needs more manoeuvre units, it needs more flying machines, it needs more intelligence, surveillance and recognisance apparatus," Gen McNeill said.

"I’m not just focused on the US sector, I’m talking about across the country."

He suggested that if counter-insurgency guidelines were strictly followed, 400,000 troops would be needed in Afghanistan.

Our correspondent says there have clearly been military inroads against the insurgency in the past 15 months.

A number of important Taleban commanders have been killed and the counter-insurgency strategy has developed.

Gen McNeill highlighted the east of the country as an example of success. However there has been an increase of attacks in the area, which he blamed on the situation in Pakistan.

Referring to the current peace talks between the Pakistani government and leading militants there, he said "there appears to be a lack of pressure right now" which had a knock-on effect on Afghanistan.

"You also know we keep a measurement of what occurs and you know of a time when there has been dialogue or peace deals, the incidents [of attacks in Afghanistan] have gone up."

The new commander of Isaf, Gen David McKiernan, oversaw the ground attack that toppled Saddam Hussein in Iraq.

His tour of duty comes at a time of increasing attacks on troops on the 40 nations making up the Nato force.
News English 12:19 pm

sex-workers-demand-rights For six months they have endured worsening physical and sexual abuse at the hands of police over-zealously enforcing a new anti-trafficking law, but now Cambodian sex workers are fighting back.

More than 500 commercial sex workers rallied together on June 4 to protest the massive escalation of violent police raids on brothels and the criminalization of sex work due to new US-backed "model" anti-trafficking legislation, passed in February this year.

The "day of action," held at the Women’s Network for Unity (WNU) in Phnom Penh, called for the repeal of the new anti-trafficking law, which critics say conflates prostitution with trafficking and is so over-broad that even carrying condoms can now get you arrested.
 
Chanting "save us from saviors" and waving placards saying "condoms protect, police threaten," hundreds of red-shirted sex workers demanded their human rights be respected and asserted they did not need to be "saved" from their jobs in brothels, least of all by lecherous, avaricious police officers.

“During brothel raids the police beat sex workers with sticks, stones, or weapons, and take all their money and jewelry," said Pheng Phally, a sex worker and team leader of the WNU.

"If any sex workers are pretty, the police gang rape them before sending them to the rehabilitation center where there is not enough food and very poor hygiene."

Video-taped evidence of the abuse of sex workers by Cambodian law-enforcement officials was presented at the event, which comes just one day before Minister of Interior Sar Kheng is due to make an announcement on the US State Department’s annual assessment of the Kingdom’s anti-trafficking efforts.

WNU’s Phally explained that after the new anti-trafficking legislation passed the police ramped-up brothel raids, began targeting street-based sex workers and closing down karaoke bars.

Not only does the new climate of fear and repression make it nearly impossible for the tens of thousands of women employed in the Kingdom’s sex industry to earn a living, but they are being "beaten and treated like animals" during the raids, she said.

“We have gathered today to ask the government to repeal the law and stop the violent raids on us, we have rights too and we need to be allowed to earn money for ourselves and our families – sex work is work," Phally said.

The head of Cambodia’s anti-trafficking police, Bith Kim Hong, on May 13 denied reports from groups like the WNU that large numbers of prostitutes were being rounded up under the new law’s soliciting clause, only to emerge from jail stripped of their money and possessions, or showing signs of physical and sexual abuse.

“It is not true police are using this law to arrest and extort money from the suspects. We never arrest prostitutes but rather we save them from brothels,” he told the Post at the time.

Cambodia’s “Law on the Suppression of Human Trafficking and Sexual Exploitation” is based on US-style model anti-trafficking legislation that seeks to eliminate human trafficking by criminalizing the sex industry as a whole.

Activists claim it was only passed in a misguided attempt to meet anti-trafficking standards imposed by the US State Department, and point to the fact other US agencies –- such as USAID -– oppose the law.

ទំព័រដើម